Learn with Phoebe ยท Entrepreneurship & Business

Learn Value Investing with Phoebe

Value investing, in the Graham and Buffett sense, is a way of reasoning before it is a way of buying: keep the price of a share and the value of a business in two different columns, estimate the value as a range, and leave a gap. These sixteen sessions teach it twice. The Owner track does it without a spreadsheet, on a constructed family business. The Analyst track does it on four large US companies' real 10-K filings, from owner earnings to a discounted cash flow to the growth a price implies. The bench in the last session checks five forecasting rules against what the filings later showed: holding out the last five years, the five-year average of owner earnings missed by 47.4 percent and last year's earnings by 70.4, and the rule a hopeful analyst reaches for, compounding the best year's growth, missed by 19,614.8 percent. No market prices, no tickers, no tips. Educational, not investment advice.

16sessions, two tracks
4real companies' 10-K filings
69filer-years on the bench
5rungs, computed live
0market prices shown

Owner track ๐Ÿงญ ยท six sessions, no code

For anyone who wants to think about a business the way an owner does. What a share is, why value is a range, the margin of safety, the edge of what you know, Mr Market, and the mistakes made in your own head. The running case is Halden Tiles, a constructed family business; every Halden figure is invented and labelled so.

Analyst track ๐Ÿ”ฌ ยท ten sessions, browser and Python

For the people who build the number and have to defend it. Owner earnings from tagged 10-K facts, normalising through a cycle, return on capital, a discounted cash flow by hand and in reverse, sensitivity, base rates of growth, a moat as a valuation input, and the memo that says what would prove it wrong. Four filers throughout: Caterpillar, Exxon Mobil, Johnson & Johnson and Procter & Gamble.

๐Ÿงพ Analyst session 1 ยท start here

Owner earnings from the filings

Tagged facts, the sieve, net income plus D&A minus capex per share, and the three places the approximation is wrong. Johnson & Johnson's owner earnings beat its profit; Exxon's sat far below for five years.

โ–ถ Start here
๐Ÿ”„ Analyst session 2

Normalising through a cycle

Five- and ten-year averages, telling a cycle from a one-off, and Exxon's 2020 loss next to its 2022 record. Where you start decides what you see.

one year is a hostage
๐Ÿญ Analyst session 3

Return on invested capital

Returns against the cost of capital, why growth only adds value above it, and growth as reinvestment times return.

g = reinvestment x ROC
๐Ÿงฎ Analyst session 4

A discounted cash flow, by hand

Two stages, a discount rate you choose, a terminal value, and why 57 percent of the value sits beyond year ten at the default inputs.

most value is far away
๐Ÿ” Analyst session 5

What the price already assumes

The reverse discounted cash flow: a price you type turned into the growth it needs. Double the value needs 14.17 percent a year.

price as a forecast
๐ŸŽš๏ธ Analyst session 6

Which input moves the answer

Sensitivity grids, the range from one point of discount rate and two of growth, and the input you must argue hardest.

the input to argue
๐Ÿ“‰ Analyst session 7

How often fast growth lasts

Base rates from the Base Rate Book: forecasts too narrow by half, earnings growth that does not persist, and the growth fade.

19.2 vs 34.6
๐Ÿฐ Analyst session 8

How long excess returns last

A moat as a valuation input: how many years returns stay above the cost of capital, and returns that halve their lead in ten years.

18 to 9 points
๐Ÿ“ Analyst session 9

A memo that says what would prove it wrong

The investment memo as a test you set yourself: the thesis, the range, the kill criteria, and the disputed evidence on value as a strategy.

kill criteria
๐ŸŽ›๏ธ Analyst session 10 ยท bench night

The intrinsic value bench

Four filers, five rules checked against the filings, the anti-lever that misses by 19,614.8 percent, the break button, and a margin of safety against a price you type.

โ˜… the bench
owner analyst bench night

Your passport ๐ŸŽซ

Clear all three quiz questions in a session and it gets stamped. Sixteen stamps means you can describe a business as its owner, write its value as a range, say what a price assumes, and name the input that would prove you wrong. Stamps live in this browser only.

What this is not, so you land in the right place ๐Ÿงญ

If your question isGo here instead
How do I read an income statement, a cash flow statement and a balance sheet, or why cash and profit differ?Finance: Reading the Numbers โ†—
Why do some businesses keep their customers and their returns: network effects, switching costs, moats as economics?Economics, Games and moats โ†—
Why is money later worth less than money now?Economics, Money, inflation and interest โ†—
What should I buy, when should I sell, how should I build a portfolio?Nowhere on these pages. Educational, not investment advice: no tips, no prices, no tickers.
I want to reason about what a business is worth, say it as a range, and know what would prove me wrong.you are in the right place

Educational, not investment advice. A reasoning discipline taught on one constructed business and four real companies' filings. Whether cheap-looking stocks beat dear ones as a strategy is genuinely disputed in the research, and the pages teach that disagreement rather than taking a side.

Choose your path ๐Ÿ—บ๏ธ

Three doors into the same habit: price in one column, value in another, and a range in between.

๐Ÿงญ I want the reasoning, no code O1โ†’ O2โ†’ O3โ†’ O4โ†’ O5โ†’ O6 the six ideas on one constructed business
๐Ÿ”ฌ I want to value from the filings A1โ†’ A2โ†’ A4โ†’ A5โ†’ A10 owner earnings, the cycle, the DCF, the reverse, the bench
๐Ÿง  I want to know when I am wrong O2โ†’ O6โ†’ A7โ†’ A9 ranges, biases, base rates, the memo

What is honest here ๐Ÿงพ

The Analyst spine is real public filings, recomputed for these pages and recomputed again on the bench. Where a figure comes from a letter, a book or a paper, the page names it and says whether it was read at source; where nothing citable exists, the page says that instead.

ClaimStatus
Every filer figure and every bench number: owner earnings, the ladder, values, ranges, implied growthReally computed from SEC EDGAR XBRL company facts for Caterpillar, Exxon Mobil, Johnson & Johnson and Procter & Gamble; the SEC refused the build machine, so the records were read from a public mirror and spot-checked against the SEC's own data; the bench recomputes every number in your browser and a separate Python reference agrees with it
Owner earningsAn approximation, labelled everywhere: net income plus depreciation and amortisation minus all capital spending, because filings do not separate the spend to stand still from the spend to grow
Values, ranges, margins of safety, implied growthModelled under four inputs you choose; no value is a recommendation
Buffett's letters, Damodaran's terminal-value rule, the Base Rate BookRead at source for these pages, named on each page that uses them
Graham's books, Expectations Investing, the behavioural papersReported, paraphrased, never quoted
Whether value investing beats the market as a strategyNot claimed. The research genuinely disagrees, and the pages teach the disagreement
Halden Tiles, its cousin, its pricesConstructed, and the page says so each time

The knowledge map ๐Ÿง 

Both tracks at a glance - hover a session to spotlight its concepts, click any node to jump in.